Skip to content

Sign in

Movie

Other Mommy

2026

Eight-year-old Bela lives with her parents, Ursula and Russ, in a household where growing marital tensions have begun to affect family life. While the adults struggle with their relationship, Bela encounters something far more disturbing within the family home.

A mysterious entity has appeared in her bedroom closet.

Bela calls the presence Other Mommy, a strange figure that resembles her mother and begins attempting to establish a relationship with her. What initially seems like an unsettling childhood encounter becomes increasingly threatening as the entity makes its intentions known.

As Other Mommy’s influence grows, Bela finds herself caught between the familiar world of her parents and a supernatural presence that appears determined to become part of her life. The entity’s ability to imitate someone she loves makes it particularly difficult for Bela to understand whom she can trust.

Meanwhile, the family’s existing problems complicate their response to the strange events unfolding around them. As the danger escalates, the boundaries between the family’s emotional struggles and the supernatural threat become increasingly difficult to separate.

Jessica Chastain portrays both Ursula and Other Mommy, with Jay Duplass as Russ and Arabella Olivia Clark as Bela.

Directed by Rob Savage, Other Mommy is based on Josh Malerman’s horror novel Incidents Around the House. The film combines supernatural horror, psychological tension, and family drama, using a child’s perspective to explore fear, vulnerability, and the disturbing possibility that something unfamiliar could take the place of someone trusted.

Released in 2026, the film centres on a family confronted by a threatening presence within their own home, drawing on familiar supernatural horror elements while exploring the emotional consequences of a fractured household.

Why Other Mommy Is on Love of Gothic

Other Mommy draws on supernatural and psychological horror, particularly the fear of an unknown presence invading the home and assuming the appearance of a trusted family member. Its use of a mysterious entity, a child’s vulnerability, and the unsettling atmosphere surrounding ordinary domestic spaces connects it to traditions of haunted-house and paranormal horror.

The film also explores themes of identity, family instability, manipulation, and the corruption of familiar relationships. Other Mommy’s resemblance to Bela’s mother introduces the disturbing idea of a loved one being replaced by something threatening, a recurring concept in gothic and supernatural fiction.

Its combination of paranormal activity, psychological fear, family secrets, and a sinister maternal figure places Other Mommy within the horror cinema represented on Love of Gothic.

Watch

Trailer

Reviews

Sign in to write a review

Love Of Gothic Staff review

Creative Visuals, but an Underdeveloped Story

★★☆☆☆
Read review

Other Mommy had some interesting ideas and genuinely creative visual sequences, but ultimately struggled to build suspense, maintain tension, or deliver a particularly satisfying story. Despite some strong performances, the film felt underdeveloped, with painfully obvious foreshadowing and a final message that seemed strangely disconnected from everything that preceded it.

One of the film's biggest weaknesses was its inability to establish meaningful stakes or consequences. There were several moments that appeared to offer some resolution, with the entity seemingly banished or defeated, only for the film to reverse course and suggest that it was never really gone. After enough of these false endings, the supposed victories began to lose their impact. Even more frustrating was the implication that one of the solutions involved admitting harsh and unkind truths to a seven-year-old child, with little consideration for how emotionally damaging those revelations might be.

The ending itself was particularly unsatisfying. Despite everything the family endured, their circumstances and overall happiness seemed essentially unchanged. The story returns to something resembling the original status quo, while simultaneously implying that the threat remains. With so little meaningful resolution or character development, much of what happened throughout the film ultimately felt pointless.

The supporting characters were another missed opportunity. Several were introduced without much purpose or meaningful development, only to disappear almost as quickly. The film also featured enormous public displays of the entity's power, witnessed by numerous people and even resulting in deaths, yet somehow the authorities remained largely absent from the unfolding events. Given the scale of what was happening, that lack of response became increasingly difficult to overlook.

To the film's credit, the acting was very good. The performances were convincing and helped give some weight to material that otherwise struggled to establish emotional depth or sustained tension. There were also moments of impressive visual creativity that demonstrated the potential for a much more effective horror film.

Unfortunately, those strengths weren't enough to overcome the weaknesses in the storytelling. The film seemed to have several interesting concepts without fully developing or connecting them, and its departure from the book's considerably darker ending only added to the disappointment.

Ultimately, Other Mommy felt like junk food for the brain: something to watch without much investment, offering occasional visual interest but very little lasting substance. With a more developed plot, stronger suspense, and a willingness to commit to meaningful consequences, it could have been considerably more effective.